Find Assisted Living in

STATE New York
  • Alabama
  • Alaska
  • Arizona
  • Arkansas
  • California
  • Colorado
  • Connecticut
  • Delaware
  • District of Columbia
  • Florida
  • Georgia
  • Hawaii
  • Idaho
  • Illinois
  • Indiana
  • Iowa
  • Kansas
  • Kentucky
  • Louisiana
  • Maine
  • Maryland
  • Massachusetts
  • Michigan
  • Minnesota
  • Mississippi
  • Missouri
  • Montana
  • Nebraska
  • Nevada
  • New Hampshire
  • New Jersey
  • New Mexico
  • New York
  • North Carolina
  • North Dakota
  • Ohio
  • Oklahoma
  • Oregon
  • Pennsylvania
  • Rhode Island
  • South Carolina
  • South Dakota
  • Tennessee
  • Texas
  • Utah
  • Vermont
  • Virginia
  • Washington
  • West Virginia
  • Wisconsin
  • Wyoming
Get Pricing & Availability for Assisted Living in Bay Shore, NY

Call (855) 481-6777 for immediate assistance and get more details


Page Reviewed / Updated – May 18, 2023

Image 1

Bay Shore is a bustling city located at the mouth of the Hudson River in New York. It offers plenty of shopping and entertainment options. There are many attractions nearby, including the Bronx Zoo and New York Botanical Gardens.

Bay Shore has a population of just under 30,000. It’s estimated that 10% of residents are aged 65 or older. Residents can benefit from the generally pleasant climate of the area, as well as lower than average crime rates. The cost of living in the city is slightly above the national average. The area is well served by hospitals and pharmacies, with the Good Samaritan University Hospital and South Shore University Hospital both being close to Bay Shore.

The 2021 Genworth Cost of Care Survey lists the average cost of assisted living in Bay Shore as $6,273 per month, compared to $4,580 for New York State. Bay Shore’s seniors pay nearly $1,800 more than the national average for assisted living ($4,500), and $1,503 more than seniors in neighboring Poughkeepsie, which costs $4,770 for assisted living.

Note: Data for Bay Shore was unavailable, so data for the nearest city, Bridgeport, CT, was used instead. 

This guide lists 10 of the best assisted living communities in Bay Shore, helping seniors and their loved ones identify the most suitable communities for their needs.

The Arbors Assisted Living Communities at Bohemia

The Arbors at Bohemia earns a spot on our list because of its convenient location near Long Island's South Shore beaches, and the wealth of amenities it offers for active older adults. The community is staffed 24 hours a day with caregivers who support seniors with the activities of daily living, while encouraging them to remain active and independent. Daily housekeeping services are provided, along with three meals per day. A bistro is available 24 hours a day for snacks and beverages, and ample entertainment is offered in the form of socials and games, along with a library and a media room.

See Full Description
  • Situated on 8 acres of private woodland
  • Scheduled transportation for shopping and other excursions

Sunrise of West Babylon

Sunrise of West Baylon is a senior care community with an emphasis on wellness. Residents receive personalized care plans and can take advantage of telehealth consultations to ensure their physicians are regularly updated on their health status. The Sunrise dining program includes nutritious meal plans tailored to meet individual dietary requirements. Activities including book clubs, exercise classes, lectures and discussions to promote physical well-being and lifelong learning. Visitors are always welcome, including at mealtimes. Overnight stays for guests can be arranged.

See Full Description
  • Sunrise CareConnect electronic health care system helps physicians monitor resident well-being remotely
  • VA benefits consultations offered

Gurwin Jewish — Fay J. Lindner Residences

We've included Gurwin Jewish assisted living community in our list because of its many amenities. Seniors can choose from studio or one- or two-bedroom apartments, each situated on the community's 10 acres of beautifully landscaped grounds. Outdoor amenities include a shuffleboard court, exercise stations and putting green. Indoor communal spaces offer a chance to socialize with fellow residents, take part in religious services, or spend some quiet time using the internet at a computer station or reading a book. Visiting health care professionals monitor resident well-being, while staff take care of meal service, housekeeping and grounds maintenance.

See Full Description

The Arbors Assisted Living Communities at Islandia East

The Arbors at Islandia East is located just off the Long Island Expressway, offering easy access to a variety of shops, restaurants and other local amenities. Residents receive help with the activities of daily living, along with meal service, housekeeping and other support. A nurse is on staff to tend to residents with medical needs. Resident parking is available on the community's secured grounds and residents who are unable to drive can take advantage of regular transportation, enabling them to run errands or attend off-site medical appointments.

See Full Description
  • Discounts offered for veterans and their immediate relatives
  • Guests welcome at mealtimes

The Bristal Assisted Living at West Babylon

The Bristal at West Babylon is a luxurious assisted living community that earns a spot on our top list for its premium amenities. The community is equipped with a pool, putting green and cinema. A grand piano can be found in the entrance hall, and the library offers a quiet and comfortable place for residents to read or use the computer. Caregivers help seniors with personal care tasks and run wellness programs that promote physical and cognitive well-being, encouraging residents to stay active and independent where possible. Nutritious meals are served daily in the communal dining spaces and a private dining hall is available for residents who wish to entertain visiting loved ones.

See Full Description

Sunrise of Dix Hills

At Sunrise of Dix Hills, seniors receive personalized care and support from a team of caregivers who have been trained in a holistic approach to senior care. The Sunrise CareConnect electronic program helps medical professionals stay up to date with the well-being of each resident, and helps the on-site nurse and other care staff coordinate the care they provide. A variety of activities are offered, including arts and crafts, games and tai chi. Meal service is included, and an on-site coffee shop is available for residents who would like additional snacks or beverages.

See Full Description

The Bristal Assisted Living at Massapequa

The Bristal at Massapequa is a senior living community that provides assisted living services. Staff is available around the clock to offer supervision and care to residents based on their needs. Residents have a choice of suites and apartments, each equipped with a kitchenette and private bathroom. Daily housekeeping and regular linen and laundry services mean seniors can spend their days how they wish, free from the demands of chores. Meal service is offered, and additional refreshments are available at any time. Cultural programs and visiting entertainers provide a varied calendar of activities for residents.

See Full Description
  • Wellness program managed by the community's doctor
  • Emergency response systems fitted in resident apartments

Dominican Village

The not-for-profit nature of Dominican Village is one of the reasons we've included this independent assisted living community in this list. The community is located on 13 acres of beautiful grounds and provides a friendly and supportive environment for seniors who require a little extra support with day-to-day tasks. Attentive caregivers help residents with practical tasks, and pastoral care services are also available within the community. A monthly calendar of scheduled activities including discussions, book clubs and socials is offered.

See Full Description

Brandywine Living at Huntington Terrace

The 12-acre campus of Brandywine Living at Huntington Terrace includes assisted living apartments. Residents can take advantage of a wide range of amenities, including a library, salon and restaurant-style dining area. Staff provide assistance with the activities of daily living, and can also offer medication reminders and other basic care services. Physical therapists and other visiting health care specialists can offer additional support as required.

See Full Description
  • Licensed nurses on site 24 hours a day
  • Programs to increase strength and mobility of residents

Whisper Woods of Smithtown

Whisper Woods of Smithtown is situated close to the St. Catherine Medical Center on its own private, wooded campus. The community has an enhanced assisted living certification, allowing them to provide a higher level of care for seniors who wish to age in place. Residents receive help with daily tasks such as dressing, bathing and eating, along with housekeeping services, medication reminders and other day-to-day care. Small pets are welcome in resident apartments. A variety of on-site activities, including religious services, are offered, and transportation is available to help seniors attend off-site activities.

See Full Description
  • Companion suites available
  • Financing advice and benefits consultations offered